The '90s Nail Trends That Deserve Comebacks (and 3 That Deserve to Burn)

Nineties beauty aesthetics were so distinct, and the popular nail looks from that period are proof. Check out the '90s nail trends we'd happily wear today.

The '90s Nail Trends That Deserve Comebacks (and 3 That Deserve to Burn)

If there's one decade we're seeing more fashion and beauty inspiration being drawn from than any other right now, it's the '90s. From the resurgence of outfit staples like overalls and plaid to the reintegration of once-beloved beauty products like brown lipstick, it seems like we're currently in a nostalgia loop of consistently reinventing the aesthetic of the MTV era. Aside from a few notable flops, it was a pretty cool time period for beauty—especially nails.

Of course, there are plenty of modern nail trends to keep us on our toes in 2021 (yes, we're still honing our at-home nail-art skills), but if you're in the mood to throw it back to the era of Lisa Frank, Clueless, and Nirvana, then you're in luck. Ahead, check out the 10 coolest '90s nail trends we'd happily wear today and the three unfortunate trends we'd rather forget.

Keep: Chunky Glitter

It's time to get our sparkle back. The acceptable glitter size has slowly been refined down to a finely milled, soft shimmer over the years, but now feels like the perfect time to reintroduce the in-your-face confetti glitter we saw back in the '90s. The bolder and more reminiscent of those holographic vending machine stickers, the better.

Get the look:

Essie Nail Polish in Set in Stones ($8)

Keep: Era-Specific Design Collages

Though most of them certainly didn't originate in the decade, emblems like happy faces and yin-yang and patterns like squiggly lines and plaid were ultra-popular. Throw it all together and what do you get? An extremely cute throwback manicure.

Get the look:

Teoyall Double-Ended Nail Art Tools ($7)

Burn: Ill-Fitting Press-Ons

Instead, try:

Chillhouse Chill Tips Reusable Press-On Manicure Kit ($16)

Gone are the days of one-size-fits-all press-ons that were too big, oddly shaped, or both. Carry out a modern temporary manicure with tips that are sized to actually fit your fingernails.

Keep: Metallic Lacquer

From eye shadow to lipstick, and even hair paint (remember that?), the dot-com era was frosty as hell. This preference for metallics extended all the way to fingernails, too. Flat, creamy nail colors are cool and certainly more popular these days, but we could all use a little more of that whimsy the '90s was known for, right?

Get the look:

Sally Hansen Hard as Nails Polish in Frozen Solid ($5)

Keep: Over-the-Top Art

Much like the dark lip liner and clear lip gloss that came to be a defining makeup aesthetic, extravagant nail art was another one of the many cultural gifts offered up by Black and brown beauty enthusiasts of decades past. Though thick acrylic nails have slowed in popularity, the over-the-top adornment of extended claws with everything from studs to foil and hand-painted designs persists.

Get the look:

Fandamei Nail Foil Flakes ($10)

Keep: French Manicures

Interest in this classic manicure style has ebbed and flowed from decade to decade, but it definitely reigned supreme in the '90s. From then to now, we've seen a shift from professionally applied tips taking up half the nail bed to daintily painted white lines applied at home, but the style itself seems to be here to stay.

Get the look:

Sally Hansen Diamond Strength French Manicure Pen Kit ($10)

Burn: Chronically Chipped Polish

Instead, try:

The Sign Tribe Remove and Chill Nail Enamel Remover ($15)

The grunge scene brought us a lot of incredible music and even more questionable nail trends like ridiculously tattered polish. Our advice? Remove your varnish before it ends up looking ragged.

Keep: Vampy Shades

Perhaps another by-product of the grunge scene, deep, sultry nail polish shades like oxblood, plum, and black were among the most popular in the '90s. These days, you'll mostly see these hues categorized within a winter nail color palette, but we're all for bringing them out year-round.

Get the look:

OPI Nail Lacquer in Lincoln Park After Dark ($9)

Keep: Fire-Engine Red Polish

There's truly nothing better than a gorgeous red nail polish, and it appears the fashion girls of the '90s agreed. Everyone who was in vogue at the time, from supermodels on and off duty to actresses and CEOs in power suits, could be seen sporting the classic hue. Thankfully, not much has changed on that front.

Get the look:

Chanel Le Vernis Longwear Nail Colour in Gitane ($28)

Keep: Square Extensions

Unpopular opinion: Long, square nails are so chic. And if you thought Kylie Jenner was the first person to rock the look, you'd be wrong! While softer shapes like almond and squoval have gained more popularity in recent years, the elongated square tips that rose to stardom in the '90s are a look we'd happily welcome back.

Get the look:

Base Coat Mini Nail Care Set ($25)

Burn: Fan-Shaped Nails

Instead, try:

Kiss Sculpted Gel Fantasy Nails ($9)

If you can imagine a nail shape resembling a duck's webbed foot, then you can envision the fan-shaped nail extensions that cropped up in the '90s. And yes, it was just as wild as it sounds! If you're looking for another unique shape to try, we'd suggest the ballerina shape aka the coffin shape.

Keep: Shades of Blue

One of the defining characteristics of the '90s beauty aesthetic was, without question, the blue manicure. But we're not talking about the navy blue or blue-gray shades that are popular today. Back then, it was all about light-blue hues, from soft powder blue to vivid sky blue, that really captured the playful edge that set the era apart. We're ready for this look to make its triumphant return to the mainstream.

Get the look: